Ontario Court of Appeal Lets Canadian News Publishers’ Copyright Lawsuit Against OpenAI Go Ahead
A lawsuit accusing OpenAI of using Canadian journalism to train ChatGPT without permission can go ahead in Ontario, after the Ontario Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the company on Friday, November 13, The Canadian Press reported in a story carried by iNFOnews. The case was launched two years ago by a coalition of Canadian news organizations that includes The Canadian Press, Torstar, Postmedia and CBC/Radio-Canada.
OpenAI had raised a jurisdictional challenge, arguing that the dispute belonged in a U.S. courtroom rather than a Canadian one. The Ontario Superior Court of Justice disagreed and concluded that it does have jurisdiction, and the appeal court has now upheld that finding. According to the decision, OpenAI did not file any evidence showing that a Canadian judgment would conflict with existing United States laws in a way that would complicate enforcement. The court also pointed to the motion judge’s view that the fair and efficient working of the Canadian legal system favoured allowing Canadian authors to bring claims against foreign companies for breaches of Canadian laws.
What it means in practice
The ruling does not decide whether OpenAI broke copyright law. It settles a narrower but important question: a Canadian court can hear the case. The publishers argue that OpenAI uses their news content to train ChatGPT, breaching their copyright and profiting from that content without permission or compensation. The lawsuit, which has dragged on since 2024, is the first Canadian case to address the use of copyrighted content to train generative AI systems, so its outcome could shape how AI developers source Canadian text. Earlier this year, several of the same publishers launched a separate lawsuit against AI company Anthropic.
Ottawa has so far stayed out of the fight. News and cultural industry groups have asked the federal government to take a stand on how AI systems use copyrighted content, but it has not indicated any plans to do so or to update the Copyright Act. The decision lands as Canadian media face other AI pressures, from AI-generated journalist personas surfacing across Canadian news to Library and Archives Canada limiting ISBNs for mostly AI-generated books. It is also not OpenAI’s only Canadian court fight: the company has asked a B.C. court to quash a privacy commissioner’s probe. What to watch is whether OpenAI tries to take the jurisdiction question further, how quickly the case moves to the merits, and whether Ottawa reopens the Copyright Act to deal with AI training.