DND’s Palantir Gotham Contract, Worth Up to $63 Million, Draws Data-Sovereignty Warnings From Experts
Canada’s Department of National Defence has used Palantir’s Gotham software since 2020 under a contract internally flagged as “not for public disclosure,” and the deal’s value has grown from an initial $14 million to as much as $63 million, according to documents obtained by the Investigative Journalism Foundation and reported by CBC News on November 7. The disclosure has put the U.S. data-analytics company at the centre of a growing argument in Ottawa over how much of the country’s defence technology should depend on American suppliers.
DND told CBC News that Gotham pulls together information from military databases and runs on closed, classified networks inside secure facilities in Canada. The department declined to say what information the software processes, citing national security, but said its security assessment found that no government data, prompts, outputs or metadata handled under the contracts could be stored, accessed or processed outside Canada. “The United States CLOUD Act does not have any authority over servers located in Canada,” the department said.
Barry Appleton, an international lawyer who practises in both Canada and the United States, disputes that reading. He told CBC News the CLOUD Act lets U.S. authorities, with proper legal process, compel American companies to produce data in their possession, custody or control wherever it is stored, so the location of the server is not the deciding factor. Jennifer Evans, founder of PatternPulse AI, said DND should disclose more, including whether its systems are air-gapped. Palantir said its customers own and control their data and that it never uses or retains customer data for its own purposes.
What it means in practice
The debate echoes choices Canadian defence suppliers are already making, from Caseway’s decision to turn down U.S. government work and focus on Canadian defence to Contextere’s AI maintenance deal for the air force’s Hercules fleet. Evans named Vancouver-based Caseway and Ottawa-based Anvil as domestic alternatives, while cautioning that neither yet comes close to the breadth of Palantir’s platform. Vass Bednar of the Canadian Shield Institute warned that Canada risks “growing a digital dependency” and argued that building and owning defence data infrastructure should be a primary national goal.
Europe offers a reference point: CBC noted that France and Germany pledged in July to examine domestic alternatives after ending Palantir contracts with their intelligence services. What to watch is whether MPs press DND to publish more of the contract terms, whether the department sets a timeline for testing Canadian-built options, and how the issue shapes the procurement plans that follow Canada’s pledge to reach NATO’s target of five per cent of GDP for defence spending by 2035.